Vector Spaces - Exercises
Exercise
We have three claims , and the task is to decide if they are true or false.
Claim 1: Every vector space has a finite basis.
Claim 2: The vectors in a basis are linearly dependent.
Claim 3: The 0-vector may be part of a basis.
Reformulate the Given Exercise: The objective is to evaluate the fundamental property of a basis for a vector space `bbb"V"`. We must determine wether every vector space can be described by a finite set of vectors , and wether the requirements of linear independence and exclusion of the zero vector are strictly necessary for a set to qualify as a basis.
Give a General Strategy for a Solution: To solve this , we will:
- Recall the formal definition of a basis , requiring both linear independence and the spanning property.
- Search for counter-examples to the "finite" requirement , specifically looking at function spaces or polynomial spaces.
- Analyze the mathematical consequences of including the zero vector `bb{0}` in a set , specifically how it affects linear independence.
Write down the specific Theory used :
Definition of a Basis: A subset `bbb"B" = {bb{v_1} \ , \ bb{v_2} \ , \ ... \ , \ bb{v_n}}` of a vector space `bbb"V"` is a basis if it satisfies two conditions:
1. Linear Independence: The only solution to `c_1 bb{v_1} + c_2 bb{v_2} + ... + c_n bb{v_n} = bb{0}` is `c_1 = c_2 = ... = c_n =0`.
2. Spanning Property: Every vector in `bbb"V"` can be written as a linear combination of the vectors in `bbb"B"`.
Finite vs. Dimensionality:
- A vector space is finite-dimensional if it has a basis consisting of a finite number of vectors.
- A vector space is infinite-dimensional if it does not have a finite basis. For example the space of all polynomials `bbb"P"(x)` or the space of continuous functions `bbb"C"[a , b]` , meaning the set of all real-valued functions that are continous on the closed interval `[a \ , b] = {x in RR : a <= x <= b}`.
Linear Independence and the Zero Vector:
Theorem (linearly dependence): Any set of vectors S that contains the zero vector `bb{0} in S` is automatically linearly dependent.
Proof: If `bb{0} in S` , we can write `S = {bb{0}\ , \ bb{v_2} \ , \ ... \ , \ bb{v_n}}`. Checking for linear independence will give
`c_1 bb{0} + c_2 bb{v_2 + ... + c_n bb{v_n}} = 0`. Since the coefficient `c_1` can be `c_1 = 1` , which is non-zero , the set is dependent.
Do the Exercise:
Claim 1: Every vector space has a finite basis. False
While `RR^n` has a finite basis , spaces like the set of all polynomials `bbb"P"(x)` require an infinite basis `{1 , x , x^2 , ... }` to span the entire space.
Claim 2: The vectors in a basis are linearly dependent. False
By definition , the vectors must be linearly independent. If they where dependent , at least one vector could be removed without changing the span. A basis requires both spanning and linear independence to ensure uniqueness of vector representations and a fixed size (dimension). Without independence , it includes redundancies - vectors expressible as combination of others.
For example in the vector space `bbb"F"_2 ^2` over `bbb"F"_2 = {0 , 1}` with the spanning set `S = {(1 , 0) , (0 , 1) , (1 , 1)}` , multiple linear combinations from `S` can yield the same vector , unlike with a basis.
Consider (1 , 1):
- Direct: `0 * (1 , 0) + 0 * (0 , 1) + 1 * (1 , 1) = (1 , 1)`.
- Alternate: `1 * (1 , 0) + 1 * (0 , 1) + 0 * (1 , 1) = (1 , 1)`.
Two distinct sets of coefficient triples {0 , 0 , 1} and {1 , 1 , 0} both produce (1 , 1). Every vector in `bbb"F"_2 ^2` has multiple expressions due to the dependence relation.
Claim 3: The `bb{0}`-vector may be part of a basis. False
A basis must be linearly independent , the zero vector can never be part of any basis.
Final Answer:
- Claim 1: False
- Claim 2: False
- Claim 3: False
END
Question
If a set `S` is linearly independent , what can we conclude about the zero vector `bb{0}`:
A) The zero vector must be included in `S` to act as an additive identity.
B) The zero vector cannot be includet in `S`
?