page2059      Lie Algebra Minute      Matthias Lorentzen...mattegrisenforlag.com


Look at the picture beneath, then scroll down to the question and click the correct Answer button.

Lie Algebra Minute

Introduction: If two Lie Algebras are isomorphic as vector spaces (they have the same dimension) , does that mean they are guaranteed to be isomorphic as Lie Algebras? No. You can have two vector spaces that look identical (both `3D` , for example) , but if their Lie Brackets follow different "multiplication tables" , they are fundamentally different Lie Algebras.

Exercise: The Isomorphic Test.
We are given two Lie Algebras , `bbb"L"_1` and `bbb"L"_2` , both of which are subspaces of the `2 times 2` matrices.
- `bbb"L"_1` has the standard basis `{e , f , h}` where `[ef] = h`.
- `bbb"L"_2` is the same vector space , but we are looking at a different set of basis elements `{x , y , z}`:

`x = ([0 , 1] , [0 , 0]) \ , \ y = ([0 , 0] , [1 , 0]) \ , \ z = ([2 , 0] , [0 , -2])`

Note: `x = e \ , \ y = f \ , \ z = 2h`.

The Goal: Determine if the linear map `phi : bbb"L"_1 rightarrow bbb"L"_2` defined by `phi(e) = x \ , \ phi(f) = y \ , \ phi(h) = z` is a Lie Algebra Isomorphism.

General Strategy: An isomorphism must preserve "structure" of the bracket. We will:
1. Calculate the bracket in the first space : `[e \ , \ f]`.
2. Apply the map to that result : `phi("["e \ , \ f"]")`.
3. Calculate the bracket of the images in the second space `[phi(e) \ , \ phi(f)]`.
4. Compare the results. If `phi("["e \ , \ f"]") = [phi(e) \ , \ phi(f)]` the map preserves the structure for those elements.

Specific Theory Used:
- Lie Isomorphism Rule: `phi("[" u , v"]") = [phi(u) , phi(v)]`.
- Matrix Commutator: `[A , B] = AB - BA`.
- Linearity: `phi(c * h) = c * phi(h)`.

Solution:
Step A. Calculate the Left-Hand Side (LHS) : `phi("[" e , f "]")`.
From our previous "Minutes" , we know that in `bbb"L"_1` , the bracket of the first two basis vectors is : `[e , f] = h`. Now , we apply the map `phi` to this result: `phi("[" e , f"]") = phi(h)`. By our definition of the map , `phi(h) = z`. Substituting the matrix for `z`:

`LHS = ([2 , 0] , [0 , -2])`

Step B. Calculate the Right-Hand Side (RHS): `[phi(e) , phi(f)]`.
First identify the images: `phi(e) = x` , and `phi(f) = y`. Now , calculate the bracket `[x , y] = xy - yx` , using matrix multiplication:

`xy = ([0 , 1] , [0 , 0])([0 , 0] , [1 , 0]) = ([1 , 0] , [0 , 0])` , `yx = ([0 , 0] , [1 , 0])([0 , 1] , [0 , 0]) = ([0 , 0] , [0 , 1])`

`implies [x , y] = xy - yx = ([1 , 0] , [0 , 0]) - ([0 , 0] , [0 , 1]) = ([1 , 0] , [0 , -1])`.

`RHS = ([1 , 0] , [0 , -1])`

Step C. Comparition: `LHS = ([2 , 0] , [0 , -2])` and `RHS = ([1 , 0] , [0 , -1])`. Since `LHS ne RHS` , the map fails to be a Lie Algebra Isomorphism. Even though it is a perfectly fine vector space map , it "stretches" the bracket result incorrectly. QED

Question

To make this map `phi` a true isomorphism , we would need to change our definition of `phi(h)`. Based on the calculation above , what should `phi(h)` be so that `phi("["e , f "]") = [phi(e) , phi(f)]` ?

A) `phi(h) = 1/2 z`

B) `phi(h) = 2 z`